La Notte (1961)
Region 0 DVD Video Review
24-03-2008 06:00  |  4996 views   |   Gary Couzens   |   My Other Content   |   Other content for "The Masters of Cinema Series"
 
Milan. Giovanni Portano (Marcello Mastroianni) is in town for a signing of his latest novel. With him is his wife Lidia (Jeanne Moreau). They visit their friend Tommaso (Bernhard Wicki) who is terminally ill in hospital. Later, Giovanni goes to his book launch while Lidia visits the part of the city she previously lived in. Later that evening, they go to a party where Giovanni meets Valentina (Monica Vitti)…

La Notte was Antonioni’s follow-up to L’avventura and is a further refinement of its themes and techniques. It’s generally thought of as the middle film of Antonioni’s early 60s black and white trilogy that he made with Monica Vitti, which he completed the following year with L’eclisse. On the other hand you could argue that, as Vitti only plays a secondary role in La Notte, that it is really a pendant to the true Vitti trilogy, which ends with the director’s first colour film, The Red Desert. Or it’s film two of a tetralogy. Your call.

If the synopsis above seems uneventful, that’s true but beside the point. In his book Story, Robert McKee gives La Notte as an example of a miniplot. This is a film which is character-led, which you could sum up as being not about “what happens” but being about the characters “while things happen”. However, Antonioni being a modernist, does not believe that his characters are fully knowable: we in the audience are expected to pick up hints and clues from their facial reactions, their body language and so on. We’re left to infer the role Tommaso (an affecting one-scene role from Bernhard Wicki) plays in Giovanni and Lidia’s marriage, as he’s clearly close to both of them. You could suggest that in some way he’s holding their marriage together. (There are no mention of any children.) The gap between husband and wife becomes more noticeable during the day and especially at the party. Judging by his behaviour to a nymphomaniac patient in hospital early on, not to mention his prolonged flirtation with Valentina at the party, Giovanni seems hardly the faithful husband. But suggesting that infidelity is the cause of the couple’s dissatisfaction would be too simplistic.

As the film progresses, Antonioni expresses recurrent themes in his trilogy (or tetralogy): how wide a gulf there can be between men and women, the alienation and ennui of modern (early 1960s) life. And few directors have such an eye for architecture – though this is more evident in L’avventura and L’eclisse. This was radically new and exciting for cineastes over forty-five years ago, at a time when arthouse cinema was more culturally central in the Western world than it is now. (It may come as a surprise to see Dino De Laurentiis’s company logo in the opening credits, but he was just as capable of putting his money behind Euro arthouse cinema as well as big-budget Hollywood.) Needless to say, Antonioni has been influential: Woody Allen parodied him, Brian De Palma riffed on Blowup in Blow Out and Michael Mann shares his sense of the expressive possibilities of buildings.

La Notte isn’t, to my mind, quite the equal of L’avventura or L’eclisse, but it’s still a key work for its director and a film that rewards watching more than once. It hasn’t been easy to see in the UK since its cinema release in 1962. (The BFI database records just one TV showing, on ITV in 1983, back when that channel did show foreign-language films, often subtitled, late at night.) The BBFC cut La Notte back in 1962 for a X certificate and there never was a video release. Eureka’s DVD marks the first time the film has been available uncut, or even at all, in this country for many years.



The DVD


La Notte is released by Eureka as part of its Masters of Cinema line, as a dual-layered DVD encoded for all regions. It is transferred in a ratio of 1.66:1 and is anamorphically enhanced. As you might expect from this label, it’s a fine transfer. Considering half of the running time takes place after dark, you would expect good contrast and shadow detail, and that’s what you get. There are some minor examples of print damage, such as scratches, but on the whole this is excellent.

The mono soundtrack is all it should be, too. Unlike his compatriot Fellini, Antonioni does take care over lip-synch, and the few lapses are minor. This is particularly noticeable considering that this film includes a Frenchwoman (Moreau) and an Austrian (Wicki), both of whom appear to be delivering their lines in Italian. Subtitles are optional.

The only extra on the disc is the theatrical trailer, which is1.66:1 anamorphic and runs 3:01. As with L’avventura this attempts to sell the film on its sexual frankness – mild today, but far in advance of Hollywood at the time.

As usual with Eureka, they have provided a substantial booklet to go with their DVD. It contains an essay on the film by Brad Stevens, a Q&A with Antonioni that took place in 1961. As usual, there’s plenty to be going on with, as Antonioni’s answers are lengthy and in-depth.
#1 Posted: 24-03-2008 10:23
Dibber
Where are the British filmmakers?
Posts: 118

It seems de rigeur to say that this film is not the equal of L'avventura or L'eclisse, but to my mind it rewards multiple viewings much more than those two films, and I find it's interesting to note that La notte was in Stanley Kubrick's list of top ten favourite films.

Quote this post
#2 Posted: 24-03-2008 12:09
Michael Brooke
Member
Posts: 650

It's also a happy coincidence that this review immediately follows one of a film by Miklós Jancsó, who was hugely influenced by Antonioni in general and La Notte in particular - almost to the point of near-plagiarism in his second feature Cantata.  Fortunately for cinema history, he found his own highly distinctive voice shortly afterwards.

Quote this post
#3 Posted: 24-03-2008 16:08
nitin
Member
Posts: 94

this is my favorite of his, just ahead of l'avventura, blowup and the passenger.  Glad to see it finally has the transfer it deserves.

Quote this post
#4 Posted: 25-03-2008 14:34
dgdg
Member
Posts: 9

Anyone know if this is an improvement over or contains differences from the recent Australian release--itself much better than the cruddy Fox Lorber? I did notice that this Eureka release is 117m, the Australian is 115.

Quote this post
#5 Posted: 25-03-2008 17:06
Michael Brooke
Member
Posts: 650

Previously censored footage has been restored, and the aspect ratio is anamorphic 1.66:1 versus letterboxed 1.80:1 (approx). 

There's an ongoing debate about which is more accurate (both ratios were in use in Italy at the time), but there's an early shot of Jeanne Moreau spotting a helicopter out of the hospital window that seems to point towards 1.66:1 - it's right at the top of the frame, and almost invisible on the R4 release.

Another point worth noting about the MoC release is that the subtitles are outstanding - not merely in terms of content but also sensitive positioning.  Antonioni sometimes frames characters with their mouths near the bottom of the frame, and in these cases the subtitles have been moved further up the screen to avoid obscuring the lip movements.  

Quote this post
#6 Posted: 26-03-2008 06:31
dgdg
Member
Posts: 9

Quote:
Originally Posted by Michael Brooke:


 


Previously censored footage has been restored, and the aspect ratio is anamorphic 1.66:1 versus letterboxed 1.80:1 (approx). 

There's an ongoing debate about which is more accurate (both ratios were in use in Italy at the time), but there's an early shot of Jeanne Moreau spotting a helicopter out of the hospital window that seems to point towards 1.66:1 - it's right at the top of the frame, and almost invisible on the R4 release.

Another point worth noting about the MoC release is that the subtitles are outstanding - not merely in terms of content but also sensitive positioning.  Antonioni sometimes frames characters with their mouths near the bottom of the frame, and in these cases the subtitles have been moved further up the screen to avoid obscuring the lip movements.  


 



Thanks! The Australian release is also anamorphic, but it Looks like a treble dip.

Quote this post
#7 Posted: 26-03-2008 08:31
Pro-Bassoonist
Blu-ray.com
Posts: 189

Actually, the Australian DVD, unlike what many vendors claim, is NOT anamorphic.
 

Ciao,
Pro-B

Quote this post
#8 Posted: 26-03-2008 09:57
dgdg
Member
Posts: 9

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pro-Bassoonist:


Actually, the Australian DVD, unlike what many vendors claim, is NOT anamorphic.
 

Ciao,
Pro-B



My mistake: it's 4:3 letterboxed.. It is, though, strong enough to zoom and get a very respectable picture.

Quote this post
#9 Posted: 26-03-2008 14:00
Local Hero
Member
Posts: 39

I happen to own the Australian codefree release and I can confirm that the picture quality is really good on a LCD TV. Extra-wise, the Australian release is quite strong, too: It doesn't have a booklet, but it offers an audio commentary by a film historian (which I haven't heard as yet), the original Italian trailer and a fascinating, almost hour-long documentary which chronicles Antonioni's career from "La gente di po" (1947) up to "Beyond the Clouds" (1995) and includes a lot of contemporary interviews with the master himself explaining the ideas behind his work. And you watch him gracefully ageing throughout the years. I'm tempted to say this docu alone is worth the purchase of the Australian DVD. In any case, we have here a most respectable alternative to the MoC. I'd love to see a face-to-face comparison on dvdbeaver soon.

Quote this post
#10 Posted: 03-04-2008 14:04
dgdg
Member
Posts: 9

I triple dipped. The MoC release is a bit disappointing and the nine for video above seems to be a lapse--it's five or six at best. It's riddled with edge enhancement, soft and appears very 'digital' (the DVDBeaver captures really show this well), with an unstable image especially the lines of buildings--which is a problem as much of the film is taken up with looking at architecture. It is, though, better in terms of contrast, sharpness and stability than either of the previous releases. Not definitive though. Come on Criterion and match your peerless L'Eclisse.

Quote this post


Comment on this content - sign up for a Digital Fix login, or sign in now
Username:
Password:
Remember:
Register now!