Harold Lloyd: The Definitive Collection in July
News
04-06-2007 17:04  |  6772 views   |   Dave Foster   |   My Other Content
 
Optimum Home Entertainment have announced the UK DVD release of Harold Lloyd: The Definitive Collection on 9th July 2007. Harold Lloyd was one of the great comic stars of the cinema, a genius on a par with Chaplin and Keaton. Born in Burchard, Nebraska, on April 20, 1893 Lloyd was acting at an early age with theatrical repertory companies. He made his film debut as an extra in a 1913 one-reel film for the Edison Film Company. He became friends with another extra, Hal Roach, and when Roach formed his own film company, he invited Lloyd to join him.

Lloyd’s initial comic characterization was a tramp character called Willie Work. After a series of partings over money and subsequent reconciliations, Roach and Lloyd created a new character, called Lonesome Luke, which became popular, despite Lloyd’s dislike of imitating Charlie Chaplin, which the film distributor, Pathé, demanded.

Then Lloyd found the idea that was to become his trademark, and change him from a good comedian to a major star: the glasses. Lloyd persuaded Roach and his distributor to abandon Lonesome Luke and in 1917 Lloyd shed grotesque comedy clothes and characterizations for a pair of horn-rimmed glasses. In doing so, Lloyd created an American archetype, an optimistic and determined go-getter sporting spectacles and a toothy smile.

Lloyd retained the “Glass Character” (as Lloyd called his comic persona) throughout the rest of his motion picture career, which spanned 34 years and over 200 comedies. Among his most famous films are Grandma's Boy (1922), Safety Last! (1923), The Freshman (1925), The Kid Brother (1927), Speedy (1928), and Movie Crazy (1932), all included here amongst many other gems in this most comprehensive of collections.

This 9-disc collection holds 16 features and 12 short films along with exclusive extra features.

A breakdown of each disc follows…

Disc 1:

Features: Safety Last! and Girl Shy
Shorts: An Eastern Westerner (24mins)
Extras: Safety Last! commentary and mini biographies (29mins)

Disc 2:

Features: The Cat’s Paw and The Milky Way
Extras: Harold’s Hollywood Featurette (8mins)

Disc 3:

Features: Why Worry?, Dr. Jack and Feet First

Disc 4:

Features: The Kid Brother
Shorts: Bumping into Broadway (25mins) and Billy Blazes, Esq. (13mins)
Extras: The Kid Brother commentary, Home Movies (28mins), Leonard Maitlin Featurette (20mins) - more on these below...


'Home Movies' includes:
Lloyd Family at the Beach - 1926
Colour Process - 1920
Lloyd Family at Irving St. House
Gloria's Birthday Party at Irving Street
Lloyd Family at Greenacres - 1932
Lloyd Family with Children - 1932
Gloria's Birthday Party at Greenacres
Golf at Greenacres
Gloria and Friends Play at Greenacres
Mildred with Children at Greenacres - 1949
Shriners
Harold Lloyd Funeral

'Leonard Maltin Featurette' includes:
Fresh From The Farm - 1893-1913
Pay Your Dues - 1914-1916
I'm On My Way - 1917-1919
Twixt Love and Fire - 1920-1923
High and Dizzy - 1924-1926
Hear 'Em Rave - 1927-1928
Just Neighbours - 1929
Never Weaken - 1930 - 1936
Going, Going, Gone! - 1937-1947
Move On - 1948-1953
It's A Wild Life - 1954-1971
Down Memory Lane - 1975-2005

Disc 5:

Features: Hot Water
Shorts: Now or Never (35mins), High and Dizzy (26mins) and Get Out and Get Under (25mins)
Extras: Greenacres Featurette (15mins), Remembering Harold Featurette (11mins), Keep ‘Em Rollin Featurette (15mins) and Finding Harold Featurette (3mins)

Disc 6:

Features: Speedy and Grandma’s Boy
Shorts: Never Weaken (29mins) and Haunted Spooks (25mins)
Extras: Speedy commentary, Haunted Spooks commentary

Disc 7:

Features: A Sailor-Made Man and For Heaven’s Sake
Shorts: Number, Please? (25mins), Among Those Present (35mins) and I Do (24mins)

Disc 8:

Features: Movie Crazy and Welcome Danger
Extras: From the Vault (47mins) - more on this below...

'From the Vault' includes:
US Gala Dinner with Harold Lloyd
AFI Seminar (audio)
Old Gold Comedy Theatre (audio)
City of La Fiesta Parade Promo
World of Comedy trailer
Social Security in Action
The Academy Awards - 1952

Disc 9:

Features: The Freshman
Shorts: From Hand to Mouth (22mins) and Ask Father (13mins)
Extras: The Freshman commentary, and...

'Memories, Secrets and Gags' - interviews with Lloyd friends and experts:

Kevin Brownlow (13:22)
Richard Correll & David Nowell (34:08)
Mark Gordon (1:22)
Tab Hunter (1:52)
John Landis (2:31)
Annette D'Agostino Lloyd (1:28)
Debbie Reynolds (4:26)
Robert Rosen, Robert R. Gitt & Jere Guldin (5:00)
Robert Wagner (3:23)
Douglas Wick (1:18)

#1 Posted: 04-06-2007 19:12
spionkop
Member
Posts: 91
Seems to be missing a few commentaries from the US release version.
The only difference film-wise is the addition of Lloyd's first talkie "Welcome Danger" although the silent version of this film could also been included.
Quote this post
#2 Posted: 05-06-2007 18:03
Jayszen
Member
Posts: 5
Again, R1 versions win hands down. What is going on with Optimum? So many of their recent releases have little to offer other than just the core content and yet better versions are available elsewhere. The R1 Warner The Harold Lloyd Comedy Collection Vols. 1-3 boxset has more to offer. Perhaps Optimum wish to take advantage of the apparent discontinuation of this release. I suggest those interested in the R1 set grab the few available sets now online. The individual vols.1, 2 & 3 have also appear to have been discontinued. 
Quote this post
#3 Posted: 23-07-2007 23:07
Michael Brooke
Member
Posts: 650
I have a set of check discs of the Optimum edition, and there's a lot of extra material that isn't mentioned in those specs above.  I haven't done a detailed item-by-item comparison with the R1 release, but the two are clearly a lot closer than has been implied.  

Here's what else you get:

DISCS ONE-THREE
As described

DISC FOUR
'The Kid Brother' has a commentary

'Home Movies' includes:
Lloyd Family at the Beach - 1926
Colour Process - 1920
Lloyd Family at Irving St. House
Gloria's Birthday Party at Irving Street
Lloyd Family at Greenacres - 1932
Lloyd Family with Children - 1932
Gloria's Birthday Party at Greenacres
Golf at Greenacres
Gloria and Friends Play at Greenacres
Mildred with Children at Greenacres - 1949
Shriners
Harold Lloyd Funeral

'Leonard Maltin Featurette' includes:
Fresh From The Farm - 1893-1913
Pay Your Dues - 1914-1916
I'm On My Way - 1917-1919
Twixt Love and Fire - 1920-1923
High and Dizzy - 1924-1926
Hear 'Em Rave - 1927-1928
Just Neighbours - 1929
Never Weaken - 1930 - 1936
Going, Going, Gone! - 1937-1947
Move On - 1948-1953
It's A Wild Life - 1954-1971
Down Memory Lane - 1975-2005

DISC FIVE
As described

DISC SIX
'Speedy' has a commentary
'Haunted Spooks' has a commentary

DISC SEVEN
As described

DISC EIGHT
'From the Vault' includes:
US Gala Dinner with Harold Lloyd
AFI Seminar (audio)
Old Gold Comedy Theatre (audio)
City of La Fiesta Parade Promo
World of Comedy trailer
Social Security in Action
The Academy Awards - 1952

DISC NINE
'The Freshman' has a commentary

'Memories, Secrets and Gags' - interviews with Lloyd friends and experts:

Kevin Brownlow (13:22)
Richard Correll & David Nowell (34:08)
Mark Gordon (1:22)
Tab Hunter (1:52)
John Landis (2:31)
Annette D'Agostino Lloyd (1:28)
Debbie Reynolds (4:26)
Robert Rosen, Robert R. Gitt & Jere Guldin (5:00)
Robert Wagner (3:23)
Douglas Wick (1:18)

There's also a stills gallery (40 images), full Lloyd filmography and a recording of an elderly Lloyd introducing The Freshman

On the basis of a casual glance down the specs, I'd say that the R1 appears to have slightly more extras (and a Spanish subtitle option), but the Optimum has one more feature ('Welcome Danger', which wasn't restored in time for the R1 release) - and certainly seems to match all the significant extras, including all the commentaries.  So I'd say it looks much closer to a draw than it initially seemed - and I'd personally favour the Optimum for the additional feature.
Quote this post
#4 Posted: 05-08-2007 16:53
DaveF
Administrator
Posts: 2318
Thanks for the details Michael, I've updated the news piece with the information.
Quote this post


Comment on this content - sign up for a Digital Fix login, or sign in now
Username:
Password:
Remember:
Register now!